August 8, 2020
Objective:
To control the circulation of black money and create a disincentive against cash economy, the Government introduced section 269ST (Mode of undertaking transactions) w.e.f 01 April 2017.
Provision:
Exceptions: The section is not applicable in the following circumstances:
Consequences of violation: Section 271AD deals with the violation of the section. Penalty = Amount received
Illustrations:
Scenario | Particulars | Implications for | Applicability of the section | |
A | Receipt in a Single day | Mr. X paid Rs. 2,50,000/- (Pertaining to 3 different invoices of different dates) in cash to Mr. Y on 25/10/2019 for goods purchased | Mr. Y | Yes, as the same was received in a single day irrespective of the number and dates of the invoices. |
B | Receipt w.r.t single transaction | Mr. A received Rs. 2,50,000 /- in cash from Mr. B over a period of 3 days for services provided for a total consideration of Rs. 3,00,000/- | Mr. A | Yes, as the entire amount pertains to one single transaction. |
C | Transaction relating to one event or occasion from a person | Mr. C (event manager) receives Rs. 3,00,000/- for food, decoration, and music billed vide different invoices (Rs.1,00,000/- for each service) in cash from Mr. D | Mr. C | Yes, as the entire amount pertains to one specific event or occasion. |
D | Transaction of gift | Ms. D receives Rs.3,00,000/- in cash as gift on her wedding | Ms. D | Yes, as the section does not differentiate between business or personal purpose, though such amount will not be treated as income in the hands of Ms. D. |
E | Loan or deposit or specified sum | Mr. Y received Rs. 3,00,000/- as rental security deposit in cash for his let out commercial property | Mr. Y | No, as the transaction shall be covered u/s. 269SS which is an exception to the section. |
F | Receipt of installment by a NBFC / HFC | NBFC receives Rs. 15,000/- as installment towards loan taken by Mr. M. However, the total of all instalments amounts to Rs. 2,20,000/- | NBFC | No, as single installment constitutes a single transaction and all the installments shall not be aggregated to determine the limit of Rs. 2,00,000/- as clarified by CBDT. |
G | Cash withdrawal | M/s. ABC Associates withdrew Rs. 3,00,000/- from the bank account on single day | M/s. ABC Associates | No, as there is no restriction on cash withdrawal from bank as clarified by CBDT. |
Conclusion: While the introduction of this section is an aggressive step to curb black money, it is practically difficult to implement it in a country like India. While it is difficult to track such transactions, there are chances that genuine cases will get penalized.